Seismic Resilience and Adaptation of Infrastructure and Social Systems to Changing Arctic Environments
Navigating the New Arctic (NNA) is one of NSF's 10 Big Ideas. NNA projects address convergence scientific challenges in the rapidly changing Arctic. The Arctic research is needed to inform the economy, security and resilience of the Nation, the larger region and the globe. NNA empowers new research partnerships from local to international scales, diversifies the next generation of Arctic researchers, enhances efforts in formal and informal education, and integrates the co-production of knowledge where appropriate. This award fulfills part of that aim by supporting planning activities with clear potential to develop novel, leading edge research ideas and approaches to address NNA goals. It integrates aspects of the natural environment, built environment, and social systems to address important societal challenges at this intersection, and engages internationally and with local and Indigenous communities.
Alaska experiences thousands of earthquakes every year, including historical major events that have disrupted and severely damaged infrastructure and lifeline networks. Given the accelerating environmental, ecological, and social changes as the Arctic climate warms, including changes in soil properties, it is critical to understand how infrastructure and society respond to seismic events. Seismic assessments of infrastructure, post-earthquake recovery, and future planning must simultaneously consider natural environment, built infrastructure, and social systems. This project addresses an urgent need for Arctic residents to develop strategies to respond to seismic events. Resilient infrastructure linked with social systems is crucial to the state of Alaska and beyond, which will impact the state’s economic competitiveness, national security, and residents’ safety and health. The project engages Indigenous communities through surveys, local tribal conferences, and public forums as an important way to increase public awareness and involvement in the decision-making process. In addition, the project involves education and outreach efforts including graduate student training in interdisciplinary research, curriculum enhancement and communicating with Indigenous communities to build foundations for future collaboration and engagement.
This award funds the development of a diverse and convergent research team, builds technical and community capacity, and enables planning for an integrated cross-disciplinary and well-defined research strategy to address seismic resilience of Arctic infrastructure and social systems influenced by changes in climate. An initial survey from the University of Alaska at Fairbanks (UAF) students, governmental agencies, and industry along with a discussion session at an Alaska Tribal Conference on Environmental Management informs the planned workshop designed to assess the state-of-the-art and practice and determine research needs, challenges, and priorities. An international workshop is being organized where subject experts from different disciplines and perspectives will collectively envision future research needs and action items to enhance seismic resiliency of Arctic at the intersection of natural, built, and social environments. The workshop brings a group of researchers, stakeholders, and decision makers from the U.S., internationally, and from Alaskan Indigenous communities to exchange knowledge, experience, expectations. The project scope engages Arctic residents through town-hall forums in three local communities, which is a necessary step to build the relationships needed for future co-production of knowledge.
This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.
This collaborative project between Ghayoomi (2022589, UNH) and Kholodov (2022628, UAF) aims to build a research team and plan convergence research to address seismic resilience in Arctic Social Systems from late summer 2020 through 2022. An initial survey of UAF students, government officials as well as a session at the Alaska Tribal Conference on Environmental Management will lay the groundwork for an international workshop in Anchorage to assess state of the art seismic resilience in coastal Alaska and determine research needs. The workshop (planned for year 2) will bring together a team of experts comprised of earthquake engineers, seismologists, permafrost experts and geo-hydrologists, climate scientists, social scientists, urban developers, economists, and social-technical risk and uncertainty experts who will be well-positioned to tackle this problem at the intersection of natural environment, built environment, and social systems. Data gathering, meetings and workshop; no fieldwork will be conducted. The outcome of the initial survey and workshop outcome will be presented and discussed with Arctic community in three town-hall forums.
Co-Principal Investigators
Project Outcomes
Arctic change is accelerating environmentally, ecologically, and socially. In order to understand how these changes interact and how they influence seismic response and consequences, a holistic investigation is required that incorporates human impacts, natural system, and built infrastructure. In order to protect Arctic infrastructure and environmental systems, and also design new sustainable systems, scientists and engineers need to deal with the threats facing the infrastructure and communities due to natural hazards like earthquakes. This includes resilient systems that consider natural, built, and social environments and adaptation practices that reduce the risks and uncertainty in dealing with these hazards, while considering the local and global climatic changes.
Alaska is one of the most seismically active states in the U.S. with some of the largest historic earthquakes, especially in North America. Seismically induced hazards can impact both natural environments. As the built environment expands worldwide and becomes more interdependent, the risk of earthquake-induced damage becomes harder to evaluate. Thus, an ideal resiliency model requires consideration of multiple interdependent variables, including climate variability, infrastructure management and planning, risk assessment and uncertainty measures, disaster response and mitigation, institutional capacity, and social-economic repercussions. A robust understanding of community response requires involvement of diverse interest groups with differing priorities, capacities, and social positions.
This collaborative planning project formed convergent research team and built technical and community capacity to investigate the resilience of Arctic infrastructure and social systems in response to seismic events in light of a changing climate. The project brought together a research community across disciplines to set the groundwork for future research in seismic resiliency of Arctic systems. The specific outcomes of the project include:
- In-depth semi-structured interviews were conducted using a dedicated protocol and array of questions to guide interviews. These were performed via videoconference, transcribed, and thematically coded using qualitative data management software. The interviews identified major challenges and opportunities in addressing Arctic seismic resilience.
- A workshop was hosted by the University of New Hampshire in Anchorage, Alaska on September 20-22, 2021, to facilitate convergent discussions and to assess and prioritize the research needs and future directions of seismic resilience in the Arctic. The core objectives were to (1) foster collaboration among the diverse group of participants; (2) identify, define, and prioritize research needs and ideas; and (3) propose strategies for outreach to Indigenous communities and best practices for co-production of knowledge. Live survey questions throughout the workshop helped to understand attendees’ big picture perspectives and prepare participants for insightful discussions and follow-on group activities. Participants were asked to share their main concerns or priority topics for (a) seismic resilience of Arctic and sub-Arctic built infrastructure and (b) seismic resilience of the Arctic and sub-Arctic social systems and whether those are significantly impacted by climate change. The workshop identified priority concerns in the seismic resilience of built infrastructure and social systems and how climate change will affect these concerns. Participants drafted six convergent research ideas to address the highest priority concerns and motivate future research initiatives. More data is available on the workshop website at https://sites.google.com/view/1st-arctic-seismic-resiliency/home. This workshop brought together about 50 participants from different sectors including researchers, policy makers, first responders and disaster recovery planners, industry partners, local and Indigenous community representatives, and other related stakeholders. The participants’ expertise covered a wide range of disciplines ranging from earthquake engineers, seismologists, permafrost experts, geo-hydrologists, climate scientists, disaster managers and urban developers, social scientists, risk and uncertainty experts, economists and community development professionals. Although most of the attendees were from the United States, researchers from Greenland (Denmark), Iceland, and Japan also participated.
- Interaction between local communities and natural and built environments is certainly the key to the success of convergence research. To address the community’s apprehensions concerning climate change and the resilience of infrastructure in Alaska, a community outreach initiative was undertaken in Copper River Valley, Alaska, on June 1, 2023. During this gathering, participants engaged in various group activities aimed at deliberating their concerns and perspectives. The primary focus was on understanding their most critical needs during emergency (i.e., earthquake) scenarios. Participants were prompted to think about four key questions including climate stressors in their locality, seismic events, damages, and works to be done.
- The findings from the workshop and other activities were integrated to identify influential variables for seismic infrastructure resilience in the Arctic, considering both engineering and coupled human-environment perspectives. This knowledge and data were leveraged to develop a preliminary system dynamics model to simulate seismic resilience processes.
- Three PhD students and three undergraduate researchers were involved in this project. They received mentoring and training, gained knowledge, and engaged in experiences on seismic resiliency and earthquake impacts on civil infrastructure and social systems. The graduate students were also involved in publications and dissemination of the research outcome.