Landscape evolution and adapting to change in ice-rich permafrost systems

Abstract

Ice-rich permafrost is ground that is frozen all year round for two or more years and contains particularly large amounts of water that will be released upon thawing. This ice is the element of Arctic landscapes most susceptible to climate warming. Nearly 50% of the Arctic has ice-rich permafrost. For example, the upper 4-5 meters of the land along Alaska's northern coast contains an estimated 77% ice. Thawing of ice-rich permafrost affects entire arctic ecosystems and makes the ground unstable to build upon. Thus, ice-rich permafrost is conceived as having a role similar to that of a 'keystone species' in ecology, whereby if the keystone element is removed or drastically reduced, the entire system is radically changed. To better understand the intricate connections between the ice-rich permafrost and the larger arctic human-ecological system, this project is exploring how differences in climate, snow, water, level of disturbance, and time influence the accumulation and loss of ground ice in permafrost landscapes and how people and their infrastructure can adapt to changing ice-rich permafrost. The goal is to understand ice-rich permafrost at local, regional, and circumpolar scales.

The project will focus in the Prudhoe Bay oilfield and the village of Point Lay, Alaska, where permafrost temperatures are changing rapidly and there are large impacts to ecosystems, industrial infrastructure, and local communities. Both areas contain excellent examples of ice-rich permafrost-related problems relevant to many other areas of Alaska and circumpolar Arctic, so the work will have broad applications elsewhere. Three ice-rich permafrost observatories are proposed: 1) a Roadside Ice-rich Permafrost Observatory in the Prudhoe Bay Oilfield; 2) a Natural Ice-rich Permafrost Observatory remote from infrastructure; and 3) a Village Ice-rich Permafrost Observatory at Point Lay. Ground-level observations of ground ice, hydrology, vegetation, and greenhouse-gas fluxes are being conducted and remote sensing is being used to measure and monitor changes from space. Much of the response to infrastructure damage caused by severe thermokarst (thaw-related subsidence of the ground surface) is repair and stabilization of existing structures. There is an immediate need to develop more strategic approaches to mitigate damage and adapt to change. Point Lay, Alaska, is experiencing some of the most severe ice-rich permafrost-related impacts of any place in the Arctic but has received relatively little research and agency attention. Researchers from the University of Alaska's Institute of Arctic Biology, Institute of Northern Engineering, and Geophysical Institute are working together with the Cold Climate Housing Research Center (CCHRC), the Point Lay community, the Regional Housing Authority, and North Slope Borough to address these issues. Wherever possible the team are using local experience with ice-rich permafrost to help develop housing strategies relevant to many arctic villages facing similar impacts. The project partners are working with local residents, government agencies, the oil industry, and the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities to develop best practices for road and house construction and related education materials. A post-doctoral student, a graduate student, and two undergraduate students will be part of the research team. The results will be communicated to circumpolar communities and the broader public and through the Rapid Arctic Transitions due to Infrastructure and Climate (RATIC) action group of the International Arctic Science Committee (IASC) and the Terrestrial Multidisciplinary distributed Observatories for the Study of Arctic Connections (T-MOSAiC).

Logistics Summary

This project will study the Ice-rich Permafrost (IRP) of the Prudhoe Bay oilfields and the village of Point Lay, Alaska, where permafrost temperatures are changing rapidly with large impacts to ecosystems and infrastructure. Researchers will develop three IRP observatories: 1) Roadside IRP Observatory in the Prudhoe Bay oilfield; 2) Natural IRP Observatory remote from infrastructure; and 3) Village IRP Observatory at Point Lay. In 2020, due to COVID-19, a reduced research team of 4 people will spend one week conducting field work on the Arctic Coastal Plain camping near Prudhoe Bay, AK and at various sites along the Haul Road. The field trip will familiarize a new graduate student and post-doc with field sampling methods while also collecting critical baseline datasets which will contribute to the establishment of the IRP project in 2021.

Season Field Sites:

2020 Alaska - Prudhoe Bay

2021 Alaska - Point Lay

2021 Alaska - Prudhoe Bay

2021 Alaska - Toolik

2022 Alaska - Point Lay

2022 Alaska - Prudhoe Bay

2022 Alaska - Toolik

2023 Alaska - Point Lay

2023 Alaska - Prudhoe Bay

2023 Alaska - Toolik

2024 Alaska - Point Lay

Resources

Learning by Doing: Collaborative practice with the Native Village of Point Lay and regional partners on an NNA Track 1 project
Jana L. Peirce, Billy Connor, Tracie Curry, Benjamin M. Jones, Anja Kade, Mikhail Kanevskiy, Gary P. Kofinas, Dmitry J. Nicolsky, Vladimir E. Romanovsky, Yuri Shur, Vanessa Stevens, Donald A. Walker

Funded in 2019, the NNA Track1 project, Landscape Evolution and Adapting to Change in Ice-rich Permafrost Systems (NNA-IRPS) aspired to work with the Native Village of Point Lay and several regional partners to determine the best ways to engage the community in research and to ensure the research questions themselves and the data produced will be useful at the local and regional level.

2022

Research Collaborator(s)

Publications

Project Outcomes

Overview: Ice-rich permafrost systems (IRPSs) are geoecological systems associated with ground that has been frozen for at least two years and contains a high amount of ground ice that exceeds the pore space in the soils. If thawed, this "excess ice" melts and the soils subside irregularly creating thermokarst features, including thermokarst pits, ponds, thaw slumps, and mounds.  Studies across the Arctic have shown recent increases in the occurrence of thermokarst features resulting from a warmer climate and/or altered hydrology, snow cover, or vegetation changes. This project has two major components related to thermokarst: Landscape Evolution and Adaptations.

The Landscape Evolution Component focused on transformations to hydrological features, landforms, and vegetation caused by thermokarst in roadside areas and natural landscpes in Deadhorse Ice-Rich Permafrost Observatory (DIRPO) in the Prudhoe Bay Oilfield (PB0), Alaska (Figure 1). Past phases of this project found that the most extensive changes occur near road and other infrastructure due to warming soils related to flooding, altered snow regimes, road dust, and other infrastructure-related disturbnces. The more recent phase focused in natural areas distant from roads.  Landcover mapping using high-resolution satellite images and Lidar-derived digital elevation data (Figure 2) and integrated terrain-change mapping (Figure 3) documented extensive changes that occurred between 1980 and 2020 on four key surficial geology units at the DIRPO. The most extensive changes occured on residual surfaces of alluival plain deposits. The area of thermokarst ponds on the residual surface at the DIRPO site increased by approximately 13%, compared to 4% on an ice-rich thaw-lake deposit, and 0% on a recent ice-poor thaw-lake deposit. There was also a corresponding 78% reduction in the area covered by low-center ice-wedge polygons and a 74% increase in high-center polygons on the residual surface. The changes are directly related to expansion of the width of polygon troughs and loss of ice-wedge-polygon rims. Ongoing studies are focused on subsurface geophysics (Figure 4) and ice cores (Figure 5) in the different surficial-geology units. They reveal colder ground temperatures, and more excess ice in the the residual surfaces.  The transformations have had major consequences to the ecosystems on the calcareous alluvial gravel floodplain deposits that underlie the Prudhoe Bay Oilfield, the Dalton Highway and floodplains of rivers that flow out of the limestone mountains of the central and eastern Brooks Range. These systems are characterized by unique gravel-cored pingos, broad-based pingos, marl-bottomed lakes, Mollisol (prairie-like) soils, nonacidic plant communities, and rich wildlife assemblages associated with the braided rivers and calcareous loess blowing off the rivers. A synthesis of the landscape evolution component is currently in progress and will aid in developing ground-ice sensitivity maps, land-use planning, and engineering oilfields and road networks to minimize impact to these valuable resources.

The Adaptations Component focused on the impacts of changing ground-ice conditions in the village of Point Lay, Alaska. Researchers and community members in the Native Village of Point Lay (Kali), Alaska, worked together to better understand how climate change and infrastructure development are driving thaw of the region’s ice-rich permafrost. Over the life of the award, this collaboration supported deep place-based research and co-produced knowledge with direct relevance to Arctic engineering, community planning, and environmental justice.The work began with extensive community engagement and built on long-term relationships and trust. A regional advisory group that included representatives from Point Lay met quarterly to guide project direction and ensure local relevance. These meetings helped frame shared research priorities around thaw-related impacts to homes, roads, and essential utilities.Field investigations from 2022 to 2024 combined borehole drilling (62 total), cryostratigraphic logging, and laboratory analyses of ice content, moisture, and salinity. The findings confirmed that Point Lay is underlain by permafrost with extremely high ground-ice content, especially deep ice wedges that are vulnerable to both warming and surface disturbance. These results, paired with air photo time series and drone mapping, showed that infrastructure development has dramatically accelerated thermokarst processes in the community. Thaw-related ground subsidence has undermined home pilings, disconnected fire hydrants, and compromised water and sewer infrastructure. Photos of each home and orthographic mapping provide a snapshot of Pt. Lay allowing future researchers to quantify the rates of change within and near the village.Interviews with residents provided powerful firsthand accounts of how permafrost thaw is affecting daily life, highlighting damage to homes, growing reliance on alternative water access and access to subsistence lands. These narratives were central to developing a set of engineering recommendations—including pile redesign, snow management, and better drainage strategies tailored for communities on ice-rich ground. The project also resulted in public data releases, including a comprehensive geospatial dataset, borehole database, and a community-facing report on permafrost conditions in Point Lay. A scientific paper published in Environmental Research: Ecology showcases the Point Lay case study as a warning signal for Arctic permafrost communities across the circumpolar North (Figure 6).

Project PI(s)
Funded Institutions
University of Alaska Fairbanks
Other Research Location(s)
Prudhoe Bay, Alaska
Point Lay, Alaska
Toolik, Alaska
Project Start Date
Sep 2019
Award Year
FY19
Funding Track